Question for Dayton and Johnson? Email it in

Minnesotans who cannot talk to governor candidates in person may suggest questions that they could answer at an Oct. 8 debate.

Forum News Service is accepting emails at from people who have questions for Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton or Republican challenger Jeff Johnson. They will be considered for a debate the news service is sponsoring in Moorhead.

Questions also will be accepted during the debate as news service personnel will monitor hashtag #mngov on Twitter. Also, those attending the debate may submit written questions that night.

While much of the Moorhead event will center on greater Minnesota-specific matters, broader issues also are expected to be discussed, so questions may be on any topic.

The 90-minute debate is planned at 7 p.m. in Hansen Theatre on the Minnesota State University Moorhead campus. It is free and open to the public.

The debate will be televised live on WDAY’Z Xtra channel in northwestern Minnesota (channel 6.3 over the air on WDAY and 8.3 on WDAZ) and streamed live on Forum Communications Co. websites statewide. Minnesota Public Radio plans to rebroadcast it at noon the following day.

The news service, part of Forum Communications, provides Upper Midwest news to company newspapers and other clients.

The Moorhead debate is open to any governor candidate with at least 10 percent support in an established independent poll. Johnson and Dayton are the only two who have reached that mark.

The debate is the second of five in the governor’s race. The first is 7 p.m. Wednesday in Rochester. It is to be broadcast live statewide on public television stations.

Also, the first of three U.S. Senate debates between Democratic U.S. Sen. Al Franken and Republican Mike McFadden is 8 a.m. Wednesday in Duluth, sponsored by the Duluth News Tribune and Duluth Area Chamber of Commerce. It will be live on and Duluth’s My9 television.

Political Chatter: Campaigns deliver urgent messages

By Don Davis

It is breathless time for political campaigns.

In what reminds one of an old-time messenger trying to catch his breath when delivering urgent news, the campaigns fit in as much drama as possible during this time of a campaign. The term “breaking” is used in many an email subject line, followed by a comment in all capital letters that seems to indicate the sky is falling.

Take, for instance, an email from Gov. Mark Dayton’s campaign seeking money from supporters.

With bright yellow highlighting in the background, the solicitation begins, and the last sentence underlined and in blue type: “BREAKING FINANCE UPDATE: Tea Party opponent Jeff Johnson is outraising Governor Mark Dayton! Four years of progress is at risk: Give now to save our progress with Mark Dayton!”

In the exact same format, Executive Director Corey Day of the Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party declares: “ACTION NEEDED: MPR reports the Minnesota Business Partnership – which includes CEOs from the state’s biggest corporations – is laser-focused on helping Republicans take control of the Minnesota House. Give right now to defend our DFL majorities, and your gift will be MATCHED dollar-for-dollar!”

Carl Kuhl of Republican Mike McFadden’s U.S. Senate campaign was a bit less dramatic: “Senator Al Franken is getting a lot of help from Washington D.C. friends like Senator Harry Reid and Senator Elizabeth Warren. In fact, it was just announced Elizabeth Warren’s Super PAC is raising money and creating a ‘firewall’ to protect her friend Al Franken. Because of this D.C. money help, Senator Franken is beating us in fundraising, but we’re closing the gap and need your help to finish this month strong.”

Like so many of the donation-seeking emails, Kuhl begs supporters to “act before it is too late.”

A closer look at Dayton’s situation leaves the Democratic governor  looking in better shape than his campaign’s email may indicate.

While Dayton emphasized that Johnson outraised Dayton in the last campaign finance reporting period, the incumbent governor still has more money than the Republican. And while a recent poll gave Dayton a 12-point lead, the fundraising letter emphasized the 20 percent of voters who apparently have not decided between Johnson and Dayton.

“With so much at stake – 162,000 new jobs, a higher minimum wage and affordable college tuition – we CANNOT fall behind now,” the Dayton email breathlessly declared. “We have to fight back.”

‘Keep off trigger’

The Minnesota Gun Owners Political Action Committee says it wants to keep Minnesotans safe by paying for gun training classes for U.S. Rep. Rick Nolan.

A picture of the Democrat who serves northeast and east-central Minnesota attracted lots of social media attention because he had a finger on the trigger of a gun.

“The basic rules of firearms safety, taught to students as young as 12 in … hunter safety classes, state clearly that one’s finger should be kept off the trigger until ready to shoot,” committee Executive Director Bryan Strawser said. “Mr. Nolan’s actions are unsafe and dangerous.”

Strawser’s committee offered to pay for firearms training for Nolan at Mills Fleet Farm indoor shooting range in Baxter. Of course, Nolan’s Republican opponent in his re-election campaign is Fleet Farm official Stewart Mills.

Who gets the credit?

It is election season and every politician’s comment is closely scrutinized.

A case in point is something re-election candidate Gov. Mark Dayton, a Democrat, said about the Lewis and Clark project that is to bring southwestern Minnesota water.

“The area’s Republican legislators gave it lip service,” Dayton said. “We gave it $72 million.”

Dayton should not be surprised the “the area’s Republican legislators” did not take kindly to the comment.

“Gov. Mark Dayton’s comments today on the Lewis and Clark project don’t hold water,” Sen. Bill Weber of Luverne and Rep. Rod Hamilton of Mountain Lake said in a joint statement. “It’s outrageous he is taking credit for this project when the opposite is true.

“Everyone agreed the Lewis and Clark water project was worthy of funding, but Gov. Dayton and the Democrats repeatedly used the project as leverage to get Republicans to agree to more borrowing for wasteful projects.”

Weber and Hamilton accuse Dayton of playing “political games with basic human needs like having sufficient potable water in our communities.”

GOP lawmakers were working on their colleagues at the end of the spring’s legislative session as Lewis and Clark became the major hang-up to adjourning for the year. At one point, a weary but happy Hamilton sat at his back-row House seat, relieved that House Speaker Paul Thissen, D-Minneapolis, had just agreed to a solution those in the southwest could live with.

Tuition freeze promoted

Minnesota House Democrats have traveled the state in recent days promoting their plan to freeze college tuition until 2017.

President Eric Kaler of the University of Minnesota praised the effort, a rare comment by someone in his position about a political initiative.

“We’re pleased that leaders and members of the Minnesota House DFL support that goal and vision and we look forward to working with all members, the Senate and the governor to achieve that goal,” Kaler said.

But Kaler’s comment came with a warning: “If we do not get sufficient funding to support this freeze, the Board of Regents is prepared to raise tuition, as needed, to fill the gap.”

Looking heavenward

Well-known national political pundit Stuart Rothenberg wrote in Politico that U.S. Sen. Al Franken has a pretty good chance to be re-elected in Minnesota.

Republican challenger Mike McFadden probably needs “divine intervention to have any chance of winning,” Rothenberg wrote.

Dayton seeks rail data

Gov. Mark Dayton has asked about 300 communities near railroads that carry oil trains to tell him how increased train traffic and oil going through their towns affect budgets and quality of life.

At five meetings about railroad oil safety, with a sixth planned for Duluth, local leaders have told Dayton stories of long trains being parked in their communities for hours and that their public safety workers are not prepared if there is an oil train derailment.

“In my meetings with local leaders across the state this summer, it became clear that increased traffic on our railways is having real and costly impacts on Minnesota communities,” Dayton said. “This survey will help identify those challenges, and provide a roadmap for the state to address these problems in the 2015 legislative session.”

Broadband grants ready

Minnesota officials are accepting applications for grants to expand high-speed Internet in areas that lack speed.

The service, also known as broadband, is especially lacking in rural Minnesota, where officials say it puts them at a disadvantage to those in cities.

The Legislature and governor approved spending $20 million on broadband grants earlier this year, with up to $5 per grant.

Johnson: Dayton shows ‘breathtaking incompetence’

By Don Davis

Minnesota Gov. Mark Dayton’s challenger raised the temperature of the campaign Tuesday by saying the governor showed “breathtaking incompetence” in establishing the state-run health insurance marketplace and an abrupt about-face on a controversial sex offender issue.

Republican candidate Jeff Johnson’s comments were by far the harshest of the campaign and signaled the race was getting serious.

Johnson’s statement followed an announcement that the insurance company insuring more than 24,000 Minnesotans who bought health policies through the web-based MNsure marketplace no longer will participate. The challenger said that means they have to go through a problem-filled enrollment process with another insurance company later this year.

Also Tuesday, news came that the Dayton administration suddenly dropped its consideration of releasing a sex offender who has admitted molesting at least 60 women.

“I have joked throughout the campaign that as a Norwegian Lutheran from northern Minnesota, I don’t get all that worked up or all that emotional about things, but the past 24 hours and this governor have practically put me over the edge,” Johnson told reporters during a hastily called late-afternoon news conference. “I believe that the Minnesotans who are being hurt by the breathtaking incompetence of Gov. Dayton ought to be mad as hell right now and they ought not to put up with it anymore.”

Johnson has avoided such tough remarks, even in front of fellow Republicans. He often has said he is different from some in his party in that he will not be harsh. He said his Tuesday comments do not mark a departure from that, but they certainly were different from campaign stops he made as recently as Monday.

Johnson said that on the campaign trail he seldom has discussed his feeling that Dayton is incompetent, but said in answer to a question that it likely will be more prominent in his campaign as the Nov. 4 election nears.

Dayton flew back from a Washington, D.C., campaign fund-raising trip Tuesday afternoon and had little to say about Johnson.

The Democratic governor’s official office released a statement about MNsure attributed to Dayton: “A year ago, PreferredOne chose to offer its coverage at rates well below other plans on MNsure, and gained significant market share from doing so.”

PreferredOne said Tuesday that it was dropping out because of the rates and administrative problems with MNsure.

Johnson alleged that Dayton pressured PreferredOne to offer artificially low rates.

“Of course, administration officials encouraged insurers on MNsure to provide the lowest rates possible to the people of Minnesota,” Dayton campaign spokesman Jeremy Drucker said. “However, the companies were solely responsible for the rates they decided to offer.”

The other issue that Johnson addressed was the abrupt switch in the administration position about Thomas Duvall, 58, who on Tuesday was to begin a four-day hearing that may have led to his release from the state sex offender program. That hearing was canceled late Monday after the Dayton administration decided not to pursue his release, influencing Duvall to withdraw his request to be let out.

Johnson said he agreed with Dayton that Duvall should remain in treatment, but added that Dayton should not have forced Duvall’s victims to wait a year for the decision.

“After putting countless victims of one of the worst sex offenders we have seen in the state through hell for nearly a year by suggesting that he would be willing to let this guy out, the governor last night at the 11th hour…” changed his mind, Johnson said. “This matter was mismanaged.”

The governor’s office referred comment on the Duvall case to Human Services Commissioner Lucinda Jesson, who released a statement: “I review these cases carefully, taking into consideration criminal history, the evaluation of our clinical staff and the review of numerous independent experts. In the case of Thomas Duvall, I changed my position based on new information and recently issued expert reports.”

Minnesota propane outlook improves, but officials will monitor


By Don Davis

The propane outlook for this winter is brighter than a year ago, when shortages nearly quadrupled the heating fuel’s price, but state officials urge poor Minnesotans to apply now for heating assistance if they think they will not be able to fill their tanks.

“The situation is very encouraging,” Minnesota Gov. Mark Dayton said Tuesday after meeting with about 50 people involved in the propane industry in St. Paul, with another 20 joining by telephone.

Still, he added: “We’re not out of the woods. Nobody is complacent.”

With more than 200,000 Minnesotans, mostly in rural areas, depending on propane to heat their homes, Dayton called in users, transportation officials, suppliers, marketers and others involved in the propane industry to assess the situation.

Many at the meeting said that more propane storage and Minnesotans buying more of the heating fuel in the summer instead of waiting for cold weather have helped ease concerns.

Commerce Commissioner Mike Rothman said a Kansas facility that supplies much of Minnesota’s propane increased storage 15 percent. Storage also has been built in Minnesota and North Dakota.

However, the bad news is that the permanent shutdown of a propane pipeline at the end of the past heating season is forcing more of the gas onto rails, which already are so congested with North Dakota crude oil that farmers complain they cannot get good service from area railroads.

Dayton lately has complained that the BNSF and Canadian Pacific railway companies have put a priority on crude at the expense of commodities such as fertilizer that farmers need and hauling grain to market. After Tuesday’s meeting, Dayton said he thought railroads can handle added propane shipments, even though “there is no question that the railroad system is very seriously over extended.”

The state and the industry are better prepared to monitor the propane transportation situation this year, Dayton added.

The governor promised to put pressure on the railroads, if needed, “once the situation is real.”

The U.S. Energy Information Administration reports that Midwest propane supplies are 1.9 million barrels higher than a year ago, but still 1.6 million barrels below the five-year average.

Minnesota Farm Bureau President Kevin Paap called the meeting “a perfect example” of how to avoid a problem “before the government steps in and makes it worse.”

“We are in a better position if it happens again,” Executive Director Steve Olson of the Minnesota Turkey Growers Association said, recalling last year’s problems.

Besides being the coldest winter in nearly 30 years, crops harvested last fall were wetter than normal, requiring more propane to fuel grain dryers. There also were difficulties getting propane to Minnesota.

Rothman suggested that people who think they may not be able to afford propane this year should fill out heating assistance applications right away so money can be sent as soon as the federal government makes it available. Information is available at (800) 657-3710.

Dayton said that his administration is urging federal officials to release the money soon.

In addition to heating rural homes and drying grain, propane is used by a variety of businesses and poultry producers and other farmers to heat facilities.

Earlier this year, the Propane Education and Research Council reported that the country had more propane than ever, but it was not where it was needed.

“We’ve never had it in the right place at the right time,” Paap said.

Updated: Special session not expected for flood disaster

By Don Davis

Minnesota leaders say they can avoid a pricey special legislative session and still provide local governments money as they recover from early-summer floods.

A new $3 million state disaster fund may be enough to reimburse local governments until legislators return to work Jan. 6, but Gov. Mark Dayton said his administration will continue to monitor the situation and could convene the Legislature if government leaders say they are running short of money.

A memorandum sent Tuesday from the state finance commissioner and emergency management director laid out the situation.

The total state and local government damage from floods across the state is pegged at $40.8 million for local government facilities, with the federal government due to pay 75 percent. That leaves $10.2 million for the state to pay, and the $3 million disaster fund should be enough to get by for now, Commissioner Jim Schowalter and Director Kris Eide said.

In an interview, Schowalter said local governments are not losing out on money by waiting until next year. However, he added, the Legislature may need to act soon after it convenes in order to keep money flowing.

If a special session is called before Nov. 4, it would come during a busy campaign season for Dayton and most House members.

“We will continue to monitor this situation and stay in touch with the administration, local officials and legislators in both parties to ensure communities affected by summer storms are receiving the aid they need before the 2015 session begins,” House Speaker Paul Thissen, D-Minneapolis, said. “And next session, we will give full consideration to remaining requests.”

Federal transportation officials already have sent millions of dollars to the state for road repairs. Dayton said that if that money runs out, “I would talk with (legislative) leaders about a special session.”

The Obama administration ruled that 37 of the state’s 87 counties and three tribal governments sustained enough damage to receive federal aid. The administration denied help to Morrison and Dakota counties.

To qualify for federal help, a county needed to show it incurred at least $3.50 per resident in damages.

Federal funds are only for governments to recover costs for flood fighting; they do not help private citizens and businesses that were damaged in flooding that began June 11 and in some cases extended into July.

Federal officials decided that damage in Morrison County did not occur during the disaster period. County officials say damage was $206,000 and under a new law the state would pay $155,600 of it if federal officials do not provide money.

Dakota County, meanwhile, sustained $1.7 million in public infrastructure cost, which federal authorities said they would not pay. The state and county are appealing that decision. If the federal government does pay, the state’s Dakota County cost would be $427,000; if federal officials continue to reject the request, the state portion would be $1.28 million.


Counties receiving federal funds are Beltrami, Blue Earth, Brown, Carver, Chippewa, Dodge, Faribault, Freeborn, Hennepin, Jackson, Koochiching, Lac Qui Parle, Lake of the Woods, Le Sueur, Lyon, Marshall, Martin, McLeod, Murray, Nicollet, Nobles, Pipestone, Redwood, Ramsey, Renville, Rice, Rock, Roseau, Scott, Sibley, Steele, Todd, Wadena, Waseca, Watonwan, Wright and Yellow Medicine. Tribal governments getting the money are Bois Forte Band of Chippewa, Prairie Island Indian Community and Red Lake Band of Chippewa.

Dayton, Johnson agree to debates

Dayton, Johnson

Minnesota’s two major candidates for governor will debate five times before the Nov. 4 election, including a Forum News Service event in Moorhead.

Campaigns for Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton and Republican challenger Jeff Johnson have been going back and forth about debates since shortly after Johnson won the Aug. 12 primary election. They reached agreement on the debates Friday.

Johnson originally sought more than a dozen debates, but Dayton said he would participate in six, after being in about 30 when he ran for governor four years ago. The campaigns could only agree on five 2014 debates.

Three of the debates will be in greater Minnesota, with two in the Twin Cities.

The Johnson campaign was upset that Dayton would not take part in two debates sponsored by Twin Cities television stations.

“Mark Dayton turned these two televised debates down because he and his handlers are afraid of what Minnesotans will quickly realize when they see Dayton and Jeff sitting next to each other debating the issues on live television: That Jeff Johnson will be a far better governor,” Johnson adviser Gregg Peppin said.

Dayton has said that he does not see a need for more than six debates. Presidential candidates take part in only half that many, he said.

The Forum News Service event is scheduled for 7 p.m. Oct. 8 in Minnesota State University Moorhead’s Hansen Theatre.

“With readers throughout Minnesota, Forum News Service is uniquely positioned to host a debate of this caliber,” news service Director Mary Jo Hotzler said. “It’s a great opportunity for our communities to hear directly from the candidates and to interact with them, and for our media organizations to do the same.”

Forum News Service covers state and regional news for media throughout the Upper Midwest. It is part of Forum Communications Co., based in Fargo, N.D., which owns about three dozen newspapers as well as broadcast stations and printing operations.

The news service’s event will be a 90-minute debate, with news service political and government reporter Don Davis moderating and WDAY television anchor Dana Mogck hosting and asking questions provided by audience members. Questions also will be accepted before Oct. 8 by emailing

The news service will offer an invitation to appear in the debate to any candidate who obtains at least 10 percent support in an independent and established poll a week before the debate.

WDAY in Fargo, N.D., and WDAZ in Grand Forks, N.D., will televise it, and it will be streamed live on Forum Communications websites. The debate will focus on greater Minnesota issues, but other major topics also may be discussed.

Besides agreeing to debates Friday, the campaigns learned that the Minnesota Chamber of Commerce Leadership Fund endorsed Johnson.

“We believe Jeff Johnson is the candidate who best represents the Minnesota Chamber’s pro-business, pro-jobs agenda,” said Bill Blazar, interim president of the Minnesota Chamber. “His commitment to making sure we have a competitive state economy will mean better opportunities and a better quality of life for all Minnesotans.”

Blazar was critical of Dayton for raising taxes on the richest Minnesotans and enacting more regulations.

The governor debate series will open Oct. 1 in Rochester with a 3:30 p.m. event sponsored by the Coalition of Greater Minnesota Cities, Post Bulletin of Rochester and the local chamber of commerce.

The Duluth News Tribune and the area’s chamber will sponsor an 8 a.m. Oct. 14 debate, with Fox 9 holding a 9 a.m. one on Oct. 19 in St. Paul. Twin Cities Public Television will air a 7 p.m. debate on Oct. 31.

Forum News Service and other groups also invited the two major U.S. Senate candidates to a debate, but Democratic U.S. Sen. Al Franken rejected most. Instead, he proposed three debates: Oct. 14 in a debate sponsored by the Duluth News Tribune and chamber, a date not yet set on WCCO television in Minneapolis and Nov. 2 on Minnesota Public Radio.

A spokesman for Republican Senate challenger Mike McFadden said his campaign is not confirming any of the events until Franken’s staff talks about more debates.

Political chatter: Group focuses on defeating 12 DFL representatives

By Don Davis

A dozen mostly rural Minnesota state House districts could decide which party controls the body the next two years.

The Republican-oriented Minnesota Jobs Coalition Legislative Fund announced 12 districts Democrats now hold that it is targeting for the Nov. 4 election.

Coalition leader Ben Golnik said the Democrats “who despite promises of working across the aisle, being independent voices for their regions and other appeals to their moderate districts, voted lock-step with Minneapolis and St. Paul Democrat leadership for higher taxes on all Minnesotans, a crushing regulatory environment and billions of dollars of wasteful spending.”

The lawmakers are Reps. Tom Anzelc of Balsam Township, Zachary Dorholt of St. Cloud, Roger Erickson of Baudette, Andrew Falk of Murdock, Tim Faust of Hinckley, Patti Fritz of Faribault, Ben Lien of Moorhead, Jay McNamar of Elbow Lake, Joe Radinovich of Crosby, Shannon Savick of Wells, Mary Sawatzky of Willmar and John Ward of Baxter.

The Jobs Coalition list is a bit larger than some other lists of key districts.

Republicans and Democrats all along have said there are some key rural districts that could decide House control. Top Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party House leaders have talked a lot about rural issues in the past year, knowing some of their incumbents face tough races.

Republicans need to take away a net six seats from Democrats to regain control of the House.

Who controls the House is especially important this year for Republicans who want to eliminate all-Democratic control in the Capitol, holding the House, Senate and governor’s office.

Senators are not up for election this year, so that body will remain under Democrat-Farmer-Labor Party control at least two more years.

Klobuchar in Africa

U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar has returned from an 11-day visit to Tanzania, Ethiopia, Senegal and Rome.

The Tanzania Daily News reports that the Minnesotan was accompanied by four other Democratic women senators, including Heidi Heitkamp of North Dakota. The delegation was headed by Sen. Debbie Stabenow of Michigan, the Senate agriculture committee chairwoman. The State Department funded the trip.

The Daily News reported that delegation traveled to Africa to “have an opportunity to witness conservation and natural resources management in promoting sustainable economic development.”

The senators found time to tour the Serengeti National Park, made famous on public television for the opportunity of close encounters with lions, zebras, giraffes and other animals.

Two can talk

Gov. Mark Dayton’s trip to the Moorhead area a few days ago uncovered stories that some state Department of Natural Resources people were saying things not approved by the governor or Natural Resources Commissioner Tom Landwehr.

The revelation came up during discussions about a water diversion project planned to protect Fargo and Moorhead from Red River flooding. People told Dayton in meetings what DNR employees said.

“I think in a project of this magnitude and this sensitivity and this controversy, that from this point forward, the only two people authorized to speak on behalf or represent the state of Minnesota are Commissioner Landwehr or myself,” Dayton said.

The diversion is very controversial, and Dayton had harsh words for the governmental body responsible for the project.

High drama court race

Judicial races generally produce little drama and little interest among voters.

One this year between Justice David Lillehaug and Michelle MacDonald is producing drama, but probably not much voter interest.

Republican state convention delegates overwhelmingly endorsed MacDonald last spring. Most judges not wanting political ties, but Republicans like to endorse conservatives to the high court.

Things changed when some GOP leaders discovered she was awaiting trial on a drunken driving charge. She also faces a count of violating terms of her driver’s license that was restricted due to her drunken driving charge.

At first, Republican governor candidate Jeff Johnson said he still supported MacDonald. Now, however, he has backed away and says she needs to run a serious campaign before getting his backing.

GOP attorney general candidate Scott Newman withdrew his support early and went so far as to endorse Lillehaug, a longtime Democratic activist who Gov. Mark Dayton appointed.

MacDonald has filed documents requesting the state Office of Administrative Hearings (an agency similar to a court) to take up her case against Republican Party Chairman Keith Downey and other GOP leaders for not following through and backing her after the party endorsed her. She was barred from the Republican State Fair booth by two volunteer security guards.

8,000 online registrations

More than 8,000 Minnesotans have registered online to vote.

More than 5,000 of them updated their addresses or names, while nearly 3,000 registered for the first time in Minnesota.

“This tool makes it convenient for eligible voters to register, and helps reduce costs to local governments,” Secretary of State Mark Ritchie said.

He launched the online registration tool last year, a judge found it illegal and the Legislature established a system that is much like Ritchie started.

Voters must register for the Nov. 4 election by the end of the day Oct. 14.

Minnesotans head to the polls this fall to pick a U.S. senator, statewide officials, all eight U.S. representatives and all 134 state house members. Many local offices also are on the ballot.

Voters do not need to wait until Nov. 4 to cast ballots. They may vote absentee by mail or at local election offices starting in about two weeks; this year for the first time anyone may vote absentee, not just those unable to go to the polls Nov. 4.

Ritchie’s office offers more voting information at at

Next to the trains

One of the reasons Gov. Mark Dayton traveled to Moorhead early last week was to discuss oil train safety, a subject of meetings he is holding along railroad tracks that transport oil from western North Dakota.

While in Moorhead, Dayton stayed in the modest Travelodge motel. Ironically, it is next to tracks where more than 40 trains a week haul oil through the area. At one point during his stay, an oil train was parked next to the motel.

Northern, western Minnesota could affect political season

Johnson meets the press

Dayton meets the press

By Don Davis

Summer unofficially is in the history books, so it is Minnesota political season.

It is time when voters may turn more attention to campaigns leading up to the Nov. 4 election. There are local races that attract some, but most Minnesotans who care about such things will focus on the U.S. Senate and governor races.

And those key statewide races could be affected by congressional races being waged in northern and western Minnesota.

“It is huge, it is huge,” political scientist Larry Jacobs said of money being pumped into those races.

Jacobs said that money could influence the statewide races, as well as which party controls the Minnesota House.

Those U.S. House races’ impact also could go well beyond Minnesota politics. If Republican Mike McFadden upsets U.S. Sen. Al Franken, it could help swing the U.S. Senate to Republican control.

Jacobs, professor and Walter F. Mondale chair for political studies at the University of Minnesota’s Center for the Study of Politics and Governance, said that candidate-raised and outside money in the two U.S. House districts will help Republican and Democratic-Farmer-Labor parties increase turnout in critical, mostly rural parts of Minnesota. If voters turn out for one race, they generally vote up and down the ballot, so the party that attracts the most in a U.S. House race also benefits with more votes in other races.

Campaigns got into full gear in the last few days as the Minnesota State Fair attracted the statewide candidates.

For Democrats Franken and Gov. Mark Dayton, fair campaign stops are routine. Both said that instead of the need to campaign around the state, for the 12-day fair the state comes to them.

For newcomer McFadden and GOP governor candidate Jeff Johnson, the fair gave them a chance to introduce themselves to thousands of people they otherwise may never meet.

All of the big four candidates were there most days of the fair. So were some Senate and governor third-party candidates, none of whom has gained much traction.

Jacobs said the two races are referendums, but for different things. “The governor’s race is a referendum on Minnesota and the Senate race is more of a referendum on Washington.”

The professor said things look good for Dayton because Minnesota “has one of the faster-growing economies.”

In the Senate race, however, President Barack Obama’s low popularity means Republican strategy of linking Franken with the president is wise and could hurt the incumbent.

For Dayton, after 39 years in government and politics, the State Fair was bittersweet: “This is the last time I’m here as a candidate for public office.”

For McFadden, surrounded by family volunteers, including his Texas mother-in-law, it was fun. He said he loved talking to the people. “Maybe it is because I’m Irish.”

Johnson used the fair to put an edge on his campaign, opening the event demanding more debates with Dayton. The governor stuck with the six he already proposed.

Of the four big names, Franken attracted the largest crowds. Wherever he went, he drew fair goers who talked about his work, both in the Senate and in his previous life as comic, satirist and writer.

Recent polls put Franken and Dayton up 8 to 9 points over their GOP challengers. Both sides are using the early numbers to seek donations, with leaders complaining that the race is close and they need money to stay ahead and those trailing arguing that more money would help them catch up.

But for all the begging for money in the Senate and governor contests, two U.S. House races could wind up making the difference.

In northern Minnesota’s 8th Congressional District, incumbent Democratic U.S. Rep. Rick Nolan is in a fight with Republican upstart Stewart Mills, heir to Mills Fleet Farm money. It has attracted national notice in a district that has grown to the south, where Republicans are in control and threatening long-time Democratic district dominance (other than one term the GOP’s Chip Cravaack served).

“Both parties are putting lots of money into the 8th,” Jacobs said.

In the massive western Minnesota 7th Congressional District, state Sen. Torrey Westrom, R-Elbow Lake, is mounting the most serious challenge in years to Democratic U.S. Rep. Collin Peterson, who has served in Congress two dozen years.

Peterson remains a solid favorite in many observers’ eyes, but people in both parties say this could be Peterson’s last campaign and if Westrom does well he could be the front-runner two years from now in the normally Republican-leaning district. That could attract money this year to give Westrom a 2016 head start.

No one knows just how much money will be spent in the two House races, but it is obvious that if either is close, outside groups will throw millions of dollars at Minnesota.

At last report, the Nolan-Mills race had attracted $1.4 million in outside spending, and the real campaign usually does not start until after Labor Day. The Peterson-Westrom race outside spending was anemic in comparison, $245,000.

In the 8th, Mills has money behind him — from outside interests and his own bank account — but is untested and unknown.

“I’m still not clear what kind of candidate that Mills is,” Jacobs said. He could work out, but he “also could be a loose cannon.”

“I tend to be suspicious of people who are new to politics,” he said, adding that there is no substitute to having run a campaign.

Still, if Mills and Westrom show they can compete, money will follow and that money could influence politics beyond their districts

Twist on fair politics: GOP vs. GOP

Guards stop MacDonald

Political challengers proposed debating incumbents. Incumbents pared down the challengers’ lists. The governor sat motionless as two buckets of ice were dumped on him.

It was a typical opening day at Minnesota’s Great (Political) Get-Together, except, that is, that the State Fair also featured Republican officials banning their endorsed Supreme Court candidate from the party’s fair booth.

Michelle MacDonald tried twice to get into the booth, between a radio station remote studio and the 99-year-old Ye Old mill ride. She had announced her plans to campaign at the fair booth each day of the fair, but two volunteer security guards greeted her and tried to keep her out. Elected party officials, including Chairman Keith Downey, were not there.

While she eventually was allowed in twice, it was just to look briefly, not to campaign.

MacDonald said Downey told her of the decision by party officials Wednesday to ban her, but she said those officials have a duty to either support their endorsed candidates or resign from party leadership.

The ban came a month before MacDonald faces a trial on a drunken driving charge and after being ticketed this month on a charge of violating her limited driver’s license.

Michael Brodkorb of, a former GOP official, reported that one Republican Executive Council member said the panel would “fully support” MacDonald being arrested if she attempts to enter the Republican Party booth.

She was not arrested Thursday, although law enforcement officers were nearby.

MacDonald told Forum News Service that she plans to return to the booth each day.

Republicans meeting in Rochester this spring overwhelmingly endorsed MacDonald to challenge Justice David Lillehaug, who Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton appointed to the high court.

Sen. Scott Newman of Hutchinson, who Republicans nominated for attorney general, announced Thursday that he will support Lillehaug instead of MacDonald.

Longtime politics-at-the-fair observers said they never have seen anything like the MacDonald incident.

More traditional fair politics was plentiful, especially debates about debates.

Republican challengers to Dayton and U.S. Sen. Al Franken released lists of debates they proposed, while the incumbents sliced them down to a size they prefer.

Dayton offered six debates, and said he was not inclined to take part in any more:

– Oct. 1 in Rochester in front of the Coalition of Greater Minnesota Cities.

– The week of Oct. 6 in Moorhead in a debate that Forum News Service will sponsor.

– Oct. 14 in Duluth for an event by the Duluth News Tribune and the area Chamber of Commerce.

– The week of Oct. 20 in the Twin Cities, sponsored by a group that has not been selected.

– Oct. 31 on Twin Cities Public Television’s “Almanac.”

– Nov. 2 on Minnesota Public Radio.

While Republican candidate Jeff Johnson offered a 13-debate list, it appeared he likely would accept the Dayton offer while continuing to ask for more.

The same was true of Republican U.S. Senate candidate Mike McFadden, who offered six debates, while Franken said he would only take part in three:

– Oct. 14 in a debate sponsored by the Duluth News Tribune and Chamber of Commerce.

– An unknown date on WCCO television in Minneapolis.

– Nov. 2 on MPR.

Franken and McFadden were on the same stage earlier this month at a Farmfest forum in southwestern Minnesota.

McFadden spokesman Tom Erickson said his candidate is disappointed that Franken will not take part in more debates, especially one Forum News Service offered to host in Moorhead. Franken said the three debates are the same number as in the Minnesota Senate race two years ago.

The coolest part of the day, for Dayton at least, came after the governor engaged in a radio interview. A producer dumped two buckets of ice water on Dayton as part of the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge, which has taken the country by storm in raising nearly $42 million for the illness, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease.

Dayton took the ice after Minnesota Twins owner Jim Pohlad “nominated” him. Anyone who rejects the nomination of someone else is supposed to contribute to ALS research, but even though he was dumped on, Dayton said he will contribute anyway.

The governor nominated Franken to get ice dumped on him.

Dayton doused




Analysis: Sharp contrasts separate Johnson and Dayton

Johnson, Dayton

Johnson, Dayton

Jeff Johnson was 8 years old when Mark Dayton got involved in government, working for then-U.S. Sen. Walter Mondale.

Since then, Dayton has traveled the state for 39 years, getting to know issues that most Minnesotans may not even realize exist. He did that as state economic development commissioner, state auditor, U.S. senator and governor, as well as in unsuccessful campaigns for Senate and governor.

Since then, Johnson finished growing up in Detroit Lakes, graduated from Concordia College in Moorhead, earned a law degree, spent time in Chicago, worked for Cargill, served in the state House, unsuccessfully ran for attorney general and served time as the only Republican on the Hennepin County board.

Dayton is 67, Johnson 47. Dayton is liberal, Johnson conservative. Dayton came from money, Johnson didn’t. Nearly every Minnesotan knows Dayton, not so much for Johnson.

Other than both being nice guys, the two are worlds apart. Minnesotans will have a stark choice when they vote Nov. 4 (or earlier, thanks to a new early-voting law).

Long-time Republican activist Ben Golnik, now Minnesota Jobs Coalition chairman, issued a primary election-night statement Tuesday after Johnson turned back three other major GOP candidates for governor: “Tonight’s results set up the clearest choice for Minnesotans in a generation: Jeff Johnson offers a new pro-growth direction for our state while Mark Dayton represents the discredited policies of the past.”

Unless four years is a generation, that may be a bit of an exaggeration. In 2010, Dayton faced Republican Tom Emmer, who differs relatively little from Johnson when it comes to policy beliefs. However, Emmer had much more of an edge to him (which since has tempered).

This year’s race will be a rerun of liberal vs. conservative, a theme Minnesotans should know well.

Both sides seem to expect a close race in a state that has featured several of them in recent years.

However, GOP activist and blogger Michael Brodkorb warned Republicans after the primary: “GOP had low turnout at precinct caucuses, a state convention that wasn’t full and now more DFLers voted in the primary. Big warning signs.”

Republican Chairman Keith Downey did not act concerned about the low primary turnout, even though GOP voters generally are more faithful in showing up at the polls than Democrats, which was not the case Tuesday.

Neither side was happy with the primary turnout of less than 10 percent of eligible voters (“It is really too bad,” DFL Chairman Ken Martin said) but those numbers do not necessarily predict a low general election participation.

While Martin tried to portray low GOP turnout as a sign there was not much excitement for the party’s candidates, the returns show Johnson received solid statewide support. Figures compiled by David Sturrock, chairman of the Southwest Minnesota State University political science department, indicate that more suburban voters than expected turned out Tuesday to support fellow suburbanite Johnson.

Johnson earned especially strong support in northwestern Minnesota, where he and his wife grew up, and the southeast. The primary could indicate those will be some of the most competitive regions since in 2010, Dayton also got lots of votes in those areas, as well as the normally DFL-dominated northeast.

Sturrock reported that the three rural Minnesota congressional districts, across the northern, western and southern parts of the state, showed the best turnout, with an average of 27,000 Republican voters. In an election where rural voters were expected to dominate, suburban districts came close behind, with 24,700 on average, and urban districts trailed with 13,500.

In the Nov. 4 election, Dayton can be expected to do well in the Minneapolis and St. Paul urban cores, but Johnson’s time on the Hennepin County board could help him in the suburbs. Greater Minnesota could be a swing area, as usual, with Johnson promoting his Detroit Lakes upbringing and his farmer running mate Bill Kuisle, while Dayton reminds voters that he has been around all of the state a long time.

Political Chatter: Politicians fake news sites

Some political organizations are setting up websites that look like they are run by news organizations, but instead of objective news they deliver heavy doses of partisan propaganda.

The National Republican Congressional Committee is one such group, and it is targeting U.S. Rep. Collin Peterson, who has represented western Minnesota for two dozen years, and U.S. Rep. Rick Nolan, who serves northeastern and east-central Minnesota.

The sites — called “Moorhead Update” and “Duluth Update” — are at and

The anti-Peterson site leads with the headline “Collin Peterson: 20 Years in Washington on the taxpayer’s dime” while the site against Nolan proclaims “Nolan’s commitment to 2nd amendment questioned.” Neither headline links to a real news story.

The National Journal first reported on the 20-plus anti-Democratic candidate sites, which only at the very bottom, in small print, reveal: “Paid for by the National Republican Congressional Committee and not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee.”

“This is a new and effective way to disseminate information to voters who are interested in learning the truth about these Democratic candidates,” Andrea Bozek of the GOP group told National Journal.

“We believe this is the most effective way to present information to leave a lasting impact on voters,” Bozek said.

The Politico Website opined that “the tactic is legal, if ethically sketchy.”

Earlier this year, the Republican committee launched Under a big headline “Collin Peterson for Congress,” came: “Washington is broken, and Collin Peterson is part of the problem.” It was an effort to raise money.

The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee did not like the tactic,  saying that “after coming under fire earlier this year for tricking voters into donating money against their will, it comes as no surprise that the NRCC is looking for yet another deceptive scheme to distract voters from their flawed priorities and record low approval rating.”

McFadden backs tax? No

First Mike McFadden said he could accept Chinese steel in an oil pipeline construction project, then a week later he said he could support a higher federal fuel tax.

The Republican has been campaigning for U.S. Senate against incumbent Democrat Al Franken for more than a year, but still has some rough corners to smooth.

Mark Sommerhauser of the St. Cloud Times was one of a handful of reporters who covered McFadden’s transportation tax comments:

“Responding to a Times reporter’s question after a campaign event Wednesday at the St. Cloud Area Chamber of Commerce, he said he’d consider supporting an increase in the federal fuel tax to resolve a looming shortfall in federal transportation funds.

“Moments later, McFadden reversed course, saying he doesn’t support increasing the fuel tax. He later told the Times he misspoke in his initial remarks.”

A Republican misspeaking about a tax increase is a tough mistake. So is the comment about accepting Chinese steel in a state where taconite, which can be turned into steel, is a major resource.

The steel comment has gained traction on the Iron Range, where McFadden and other Republicans have worked to get support in the normally Democratic area. Saying something that could be perceived as anti-American steel could hurt.

McFadden’s initial comments to the Times about being open to increasing the federal fuel tax to bolster the Highway Trust Fund also included his feeling that such an increase only could be acceptable if there also was a tax decrease involved.

After talking to an aide, he told reporters: “I just want to reiterate that I will not support raising the gas tax.”

June primary discussed

Tuesday’s low primary election turnout could produce new debate about moving the primary to June, when some think more people would vote.

About 10 percent of eligible Minnesota voters cast ballots Tuesday. The latest count shows there were fewer than 400,000 voters, compared to more than 3 million for a good general election.

Republican Chairman Keith Downey and DFL Chairman Ken Martin have discussed the possibility of moving the primary up to June. It used to be in September and the last couple of elections has been in August because many in politics felt that September to early November was too little time to wage a general election campaign.

Many people are on vacation and most are not paying attention to politics before the State Fair in late August. Martin said more might pay attention in June.

But many lawmakers running for re-election do not like June because it comes close on the heels of their legislative session that usually ends in mid- to late-May. That gives them little time to campaign and raise money.

A big difference

One political wag noted after the primary election that Matt Entenza spent nearly $700,000 in his race for state auditor while Jack Shepard spent little, if anything, on his run for U.S. Senate.

They got about the same percentage of votes in their races.

The big difference? While Entenza spent the last few weeks traveling the state spending money freely, Shepard was in Italy, where he lives to avoid Minnesota warrants for his arrest on arson-related charges.

Big money, big problem?

Chairman Ken Martin of the Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party warned Republican Mike McFadden that rich people who partially self-finance campaigns may not be successful.

Martin pointed out that Matt Entenza paid for much of the expense of his state auditor’s race, and lost. Republican Scott Honour did the same for his governor campaign, with the same result.

McFadden is a wealthy businessman and is expected to dump some of his own money into his challenge to U.S. Sen. Al Franken.

Honour and Entenza “tried to buy the election,” Martin said.

What the chairman did not say was that Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton financed much of his own campaign four years ago, and won.

Governor race could be ‘Minnesota nice’

Dayton, Johnson

By Bill Salisbury, St. Paul Pioneer Press, and and Don Davis, Forum News Service

Election campaigns often do not follow the “Minnesota nice” philosophy, but political insiders wonder if that might be different this year after Jeff Johnson won the Republican nomination to run against Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton.

Johnson, the GOP-endorsed candidate who defeated three rivals in Tuesday’s primary election, will try to deny Dayton a second term. But he will, probably, do it nicely with a smile on his face.

The Hennepin County commissioner and former legislator from Plymouth is an affable guy who shuns angry attacks on political opponents. That description also fits Dayton.

Asked at a news conference if he’s too nice to win, Johnson replied, “Overall, I think I am a nice guy.”

That probably is a good thing, he said.

“Some people assume Republicans are kind of nasty,” Johnson said. “We are not. But being able to show that to people is important.”

He quickly added, however, that “I’m going to contrast where I stand with Mark Dayton” and said he will point out where he thinks the governor’s policies are wrong.

The contrast won’t be hard to draw. Johnson is as staunchly conservative as Dayton is liberal. But their personalities are comparably civil.

The GOP primary was a relatively low-key contest, in part because of the tone Johnson set and since the party’s convention endorsed him, he widely was seen as the frontrunner.

Johnson has a history of trying to bring factions together, the most notable coming at the 2012 Republican state convention in St. Cloud. Ron Paul supporters dominated the convention, pushing traditional Republican activists to the side.

That is when Johnson, then the Republican national committeeman, went in front of the convention as peacemaker.

Johnson, a Detroit Lakes native, called tension in the convention “the elephant in the room.”

“You know, it is not new, it is OK,” he said of the tension. “It’s not new, but it is real.”

Johnson told Paul supporters that they must realize that traditional Republicans “have been sitting in your seats for 20 years.”

“The chatter is” that Paul backers do not care about the party, Johnson said, and would not support GOP candidates.

“Make sure that doesn’t happen,” Johnson advised. “If we are all part of the Republican Party, then we all need to vote for Republicans.”

“Ron Paul haters,” Johnson said, “my advice to you is: Get over it.”

Johnson’s speech eased tensions.

Dayton has become a harsh critic of many things Republican as he nears the end of his four-year term, a feeling mostly fueled by tough battles with Republicans over the 2011 budget and a resulting state government shutdown. Still, Dayton often is seen with Republicans, and does not lump everyone with those he fought three years ago.

In his first news conference as governor, Dayton took the unheard-of step of inviting opponents to the microphone to rebut his comments.

Dozens of people opposed to his plan of getting the state more deeply involved in the federal Medicaid program jammed into the governor’s reception room.

“It is the people’s room,” Dayton said. “This is where democracy occurs.”

He asked three protesters to rebut things he and other supporters said about the need to expand Medicaid. That somewhat quieted the protesters.

And while Dayton did not make it a practice of allowing opponents to speak at his events, even his opponents call him a nice guy.

His 2010 Republican opponent, rough-around-the-edges Tom Emmer, and Dayton met in about 30 debates. They showed sharp policy differences, but both said they came away from the campaign liking each other.

If the 2014 candidates sound too sweet for your political tastes, don’t worry. The contest will not be all sugar and no spice.

Johnson joked that he expects Democrats to accuse him of “drowning kittens in the river for the fun of it.”

State DFL Chairman Ken Martin did not do that, but called Johnson a “proud member of the Tea Party” who favors tax cuts for the wealthy and government service cuts for everyone else.

Martin said Johnson “wants to take us back to the days when people were kicked off their health insurance because of pre-existing conditions … balancing budget with gimmicks … shutdowns and borrowed money from our school districts.”

Shortly after Martin took his shots, a spokeswoman for the Republican Governors Association fired off a news release accusing Dayton of embracing “every component of Obamacare,” wasting millions on Minnesota’s health exchange, raising taxes and forcing a government shutdown.

The DFL governor, he said, has been an “abysmal failure,” spokeswoman Gail Gitcho said.

The exchange suggested political parties and outside groups likely will play “bad cops” to the candidates’ “good cops.”

The St. Paul Pioneer Press is a Forum News Service media partner.